Thursday, June 23, 2005


ket8a

Rabbi Yehoshua admits in case of rape.
Rabbi Chizkiya, Rabbi Abahu citing Rabbi Yochanan: Rabbi Yehoshua admits in case of rape.

Rav Chiyya bar Ashi cited Rav: The halacha is like Rabbi Yossi who cited Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri.

Rabbi Zera asked before Rabbi Yasa: How do we actually practice?
He said to him: Like Rabbi Yossi who cited Rabbi Yochanan ben Nuri.

Rabbi Ila cited Rabbi Yannai: within Tzippori he had intercourse.
Rava (=Rabbi Ba = Rabbi Abba) cited Rabbi Yannai: If they saw him separate from Tzippori and have intercourse, there is a chazaka that someone of illigitimate birth from there had intercourse.

A platia {public domain}, what?
Rabbi Yirmiya bar Vo, Rabbi Yossi says: based on the majority.

The strength of Rabbi Yirmiya is from this that Rabbi Chiyya cited Rabbi Yochanan: an alleyway of which the majority are gentiles, and one Israelite lived in it, and something collapses within it [upon someone], we remove stones because of the one Israelite there.
And a platia, we go after the majority.

And what of {=how do you explain} that which Rabbi Bo cited Rabbi Yannai, that if they saw him separate from Tzippori and have intercourse, there is a chazaka that someone of illigitimate birth from there had intercourse?
According to Rabbi Yannai, this is where they him separate from one of the houses.
And according to Rabbi Yossi, even in a platia - for Tzippori was shut in.

Rabbi Yossi says: Until he proves.
And {yet} here: Rabbi Yossi says: based on the majority.

The strength of Rabbi Yossi is from this that Rabbi Zera cited Rabbi Yochanan: if his basket was switched at the grinder's, if one who is muchzak to be an am haaretz ground there that day, he must worry, and if not, he does not worry.
What is the difference between this and the sirki ?
Did we not learn {tnei}: a sirkit {a marketplace of Ishmaelites} that sells forbidden material one day, that day becomes a proof for all days.
A sirkit, it is possible to last selling permitted materials,
And here, I say

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home